Get SF Weekly Newsletters
Pin It

The Grid 

Wednesday, Apr 2 1997
Trial by Error
Police Commission President John Keker's flustered resignation has focused needed attention on a chaotic police discipline system that has allowed didactic, cop-hating lefties and self-serving police union officials to shred civility and reason.

Keker's ideas for reforming the system deserve attention. (One noteworthy notion: bringing in lawyers and judges as independent hearing officers and thereby removing the Police Commission and its politics from at least the trial portion of misconduct cases.) But tweaks in the system are not a cure-all. In fact, in many cases it's the quality of the people who run the system, and the rank quality of their decisions, that are the real impediments to effective oversight of police behavior.

The current debate over police discipline is largely the result of one bad cop and one misconduct case -- the in-custody death of robbery suspect Aaron Williams, S.F.'s Rodney King. In that incident, 12 officers subdued Williams, an African-American man, beat him, doused him with pepper spray, and left him unattended in the back of a police van, where he died of cardiac arrest. An autopsy said the death was hastened by cocaine use. Those protesting Williams' demise think all that beating and pepper-spraying might have had something to do with the death.

The bad cop in question, the poster boy for reform, is Marc Andaya.
But the Andaya problem began long before Aaron Williams' death reached the San Francisco Police Commission. A series of stupid, cowardly, and corrupt official decisions, starting the moment Andaya applied to transfer to S.F. from the Oakland Police Department and continuing through two tumultuous trials before the Police Commission, led us to where we are today: amid a political firestorm started when Andaya skated around unnecessary-use-of-force charges and then was suspended for just three months after a second trial on a lesser charge, even though Chief Fred Lau recommended his dismissal.

Regardless of one's position on the punishment, there's plenty of blame to be apportioned for the Andaya fiasco.

Let's start with former Police Chief Anthony Ribera, whose retirement package should be used to pay for the cost of Andaya's trials.

A hiring committee that included a police investigator and a psychiatrist found Andaya, a former Army Special Forces officer, unfit to serve when he first applied to be a San Francisco cop in 1994. The committee uncovered one brutality complaint related to Andaya's days on the Oakland force and suspected there were more. His interviews with the psychiatrist also went poorly, a ranking police source with knowledge of the committee's recommendation says.

But the police source says Ribera overruled the hiring committee, bringing its background investigation of Andaya to a halt. (There is speculation that the order to stop the investigation involved minority hiring; Andaya is Filipino, and his employment would have allowed the hiring of several white officers, under equal opportunity guidelines then used by the Police Department.)

Whatever Ribera's reasoning, it is clear that the then-chief stopped the background probe before investigators could document what is now known about Andaya -- that he had a lengthy misconduct record with the Oakland force, and that some of the allegations of wrongdoing involved racial epithets and brutality. (In one 1984 incident, Andaya stopped a man for a psychiatric evaluation and after a tussle shot the suspect nine times, reloading his gun in the process.)

Ribera turned Andaya from "unacceptable" to "acceptable" in the wave of a hand and created a problem that continues to convulse law enforcement in the city.

Next in line for spanking is Keker himself. When the Office of Citizen Complaints forwarded the Williams case to the Police Commission, Keker, an experienced trial attorney, made a horrible blunder. Ignoring the advice of other commissioners and without explaining himself, he tried all the officers at the same time in two separate trials, one on the allegation of unnecessary force, and the other on a charge that the officers did not properly care for Williams.

It's hard to imagine a worse decision.
First, the mass trials blended Andaya's act -- an enthusiastic beating and pepper-spraying spree that was by far the most questionable police behavior exhibited that night -- with the less severe behavior of other officers. And second, Keker's decision assured that the commission would see the alleged misconduct only in discrete chunks, in much the way a Simi Valley jury saw the Rodney King episode as a deconstructed series of actions and reactions, rather than one vicious beating.

If Keker created a procedural problem, Police Commissioner Jose Medina earned a Spineless Jellyfish Award for ducking the commission meeting where he would have had to vote on the first charge against Andaya, unnecessary use of force. (Medina resigned before he would have to vote on the case, having won a seat on the Board of Supervisors in November and saying he wanted time off with his family before being sworn in as a supe.)

The commission vote was 2 to 2. The equivalent of a mistrial was declared. A second trial was required, guaranteeing the political heat surrounding the case would only increase.

Queuing up for the blame gauntlet next: the very agency that brought the case against Andaya in the first place, the Office of Citizen Complaints. Mary Dunlap, the usually sage OCC director, chose to treat the misconduct proceedings like a criminal trial, where prior bad actions are often inadmissible, and failed to tell police commissioners about Andaya's stunning record of misconduct in Oakland.

Finally, and most importantly, the heavy finger of judgment should point directly at Mayor Willie Brown, who was too busy pandering to a rich football team owner to notice that his police misconduct system was beginning to resemble Bosnia. And when Keker's resignation forced him to pay attention, Mayor Willie threw gasoline on the Andaya fire, promoting Commissioner Pat Norman to the Police Commission presidency. Under other circumstances, Norman, who's both intelligent and dedicated, might have been a smart choice.

But her recent, public criticisms of Andaya and the Police Department have made her a sworn enemy of the cops, who are now howling like wounded beagles about a new, more anti-cop commission.

Andaya now faces a third misconduct charge, lying to the San Francisco Police Department about the misconduct complaints against him while he worked in Oakland. The facts seem fairly straightforward here. Andaya lied about his record. Lying is a firing offense.

Let's not screw this one up people.

Merchants of Menace
During an hour of histrionic wailing before the city's Transportation Commission March 25, Noe Valley merchants made their worldview unambiguously clear: The rights of customers who like to double-park while dropping off their soiled undies at the cleaners and who prefer sipping caffe lattes at sidewalk tables, rather than inside coffee shops, are vastly more important than the federally mandated civil rights of disabled people to access the Municipal Railway.

During two months of meetings, the Noe Valley merchants had complained that disabled ramps Muni had begun building on Church Street between 29th and 30th streets would so block ingress to and egress from their stores that they would go out of business. The assertion is both false and myopic.

Commissioner Kathleen Knox, blind since she was 14, put the merchants in their proper place last week. "I've sat through all the meetings," she said, her voice gaining an edge. "And I've heard all the arguments, and there is no argument that is more compelling than delaying access."

Knox then addressed a proposal by Muni Director Emilio Cruz, who had the support of Mayor Brown, to redesign the access ramps, moving one off Church Street and around the corner to 30th Street. This plan would have delayed the project for more than a year, posed safety problems, and cost the city an additional $200,000. "It's an affront to the Americans with Disabilities Act," she said.

Knox's fellow commissioners rushed to support her, voting unanimously to kill the Cruz proposal. With a bit of dramatic flourish, Commission President Rudy Nothenberg turned to the commission secretary and said, dry as a Santa Ana wind, "Next item."

A two-month exercise in idiocy was finally, thankfully, over. To recap for the uninitiated: The mayor, pandering to the threats of merchants, called a halt to the Church Street project late in January, after it had already gone through 11 public hearings over several years (see "Willie's Railroad Job," The Grid, March 5). Between then and last Tuesday, contract costs on the project continued to accumulate, reaching about $30,000.

While the project was in a holding pattern, the mayor sent his staff into the community to do triage and find a compromise solution. What they discovered was this: The merchants are obnoxious and selfish exaggerators who would benefit from a dose of Prozac.

Even so, the mayor opted to play for political advantage rather than sensible public policy, supporting an expensive delay in disabled access. Thankfully, his Transportation Commission resisted.

Left behind by this angry, painful, and expensive drama are two important lessons:

1) Mayor Brown showed himself to be wholly unconcerned about spending hard-earned taxpayer dollars and delaying civil rights, when the cost and delay brought him political benefit.

2) The merchants on Church Street are star-quality jerks.


About The Authors

George Cothran


Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

Popular Stories

  1. Most Popular Stories
  2. Stories You Missed
  1. Most Popular


  • clipping at Brava Theater Sept. 11
    Sub Pop recording artists 'clipping.' brought their brand of noise-driven experimental hip hop to the closing night of 2016's San Francisco Electronic Music Fest this past Sunday. The packed Brava Theater hosted an initially seated crowd that ended the night jumping and dancing against the front of the stage. The trio performed a set focused on their recently released Sci-Fi Horror concept album, 'Splendor & Misery', then delved into their dancier and more aggressive back catalogue, and recent single 'Wriggle'. Opening performances included local experimental electronic duo 'Tujurikkuja' and computer music artist 'Madalyn Merkey.'"