Get SF Weekly Newsletters
Pin It

Sand Through an Hourglass 

Over time, George Sand seems less radical and even a little old-fashioned

Wednesday, Dec 11 2002
Thanks to the fickleness of pop culture, the French writer Amandine Aurore Lucie Dupin (1804-1876), aka George Sand, may be better known for her relationship to Frédéric Chopin than for her novels, her other romances, or her generally bold life. Back in 1991, James Lapine's Impromptu focused on the Sand-Chopin romance, with Judy Davis and Hugh Grant as the lovers. Now French director Diane Kurys (Peppermint Soda, Entre Nous) has come up with a less flamboyant portrait of Sand's more flamboyant relationship with poet/dramatist Alfred de Musset.

The film opens with the couple's awkward first encounter, as Alfred (Benoît Magimel), fresh from an evening of gambling, arrives late for a reading by George (Juliette Binoche). Despite his cavalier attitude, which borders (at least) on the rude, there is obviously chemistry between them. The two start hanging out together, collaborating on a play, and at first Alfred seems intent on keeping things platonic. But, chemistry being what it is, it's not long before the two of them are copulating by candlelight (the glorious glow courtesy of cinematographer Vilko Filac, best known for his work with director Emir Kusturica).

Nothing can heighten romance faster than parental disapproval -- and, oh, does Madame de Musset (Marie-France Mignal) ever oblige! She may realize that her baby boy is a dissolute, gambling habitué of all sorts of disreputable corners of Paris, but the involvement with Sand is beyond the pale. The latter not only smokes, wears trousers, and has adopted a man's name; she's not only married (though permanently separated) and the mother of two small children; but she's also ... gasp! ... an older woman. Yes, Alfred, an innocent 23, is consorting with a woman of 29. (Quick! Call L'Enquirer National!)

In truth, it's pretty clear early on that, in Kurys' eyes, it's George who's getting the worse end of the bargain. Alfred may be brilliant and dashing, but he's also painfully childish, petulant, and even sadistic. When the two head off to Venice for a working vacation -- they intend to soak up atmosphere for a play about Lorenzo de' Medici -- George promptly falls ill. Alfred, unable to deal with the notion of nursing his lover, goes off on a binge of booze, opium, and whoremongering that doesn't really stop, even when George recovers.

Soon, the shoe is on the other foot. When Alfred's dissolution nearly kills him, George lovingly hovers by his bedside with the handsome and kind but somewhat bland Dr. Pagello (Stefano Dionisi) and finds herself falling in love again. Eventually Alfred recovers and, after a number of fights and reconciliations, returns to France. George stays with Pagello, but we know that, sooner or later, the unwise romance will resume ... with sad results.

In real life, the entirety of the active Sand-Musset romance ran only about two years, though Sand would later proclaim him the grand love of her life. (Kurys doesn't violate the time scheme here; she simply races through the post-affair parts of their lives, which is certainly understandable.)

Given its brevity, the relationship generated a lot of prose: Musset immediately turned their already notorious liaison into a novel, Confessions of a Child of the Century; years later, Sand published her side of the story, which was followed by responses from both Musset's older brother and one of Musset's subsequent lovers. Eventually, after many decades, the pair's correspondence was published as well.

Kurys is primarily interested in notions of romantic love. She has carefully selected material that emphasizes all the elements of grand passion and avoids too much reflection on literary work or any other aspects of Sand's and Musset's lives. While Lapine's Impromptu was satirical, energetic, and probably less factually accurate, Children of the Century isn't much concerned with 19th-century Paris as some kind of template for generations of bohemians to come -- or with Sand as a daring ur-feminist. In fact, for all of the heroine's shockingly "modern" lifestyle choices, the thrust of the film is remarkably old-fashioned. It embraces the notion that you can have only a single great love in a lifetime -- and that's if you're lucky.

Europeans have always been better at sweeping romanticism on film than Americans, and the gap has only widened over the years. (Light romantic comedy is a different issue.) Children of the Century benefits not only from Filac's cinematography, but also from the two leads, whose chemistry is immediately apparent. (And also genuine: Binoche and Magimel became involved during the production and now have two children.) Binoche has never looked more beautiful, but she also has much less interesting material to work with here than in her star-making turn in Krzysztof Kieslowski's Three Colors: Blue (1993). Magimel looks a little bit like a dandified Sean Penn -- try to picture the latter in ruffles -- and is effective in a thankless role: Kurys presents Musset as such a petulant jerk that only grand passion could possibly explain what Sand sees in him.

About The Author

Andy Klein


Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

Popular Stories

  1. Most Popular Stories
  2. Stories You Missed
  1. Most Popular


  • clipping at Brava Theater Sept. 11
    Sub Pop recording artists 'clipping.' brought their brand of noise-driven experimental hip hop to the closing night of 2016's San Francisco Electronic Music Fest this past Sunday. The packed Brava Theater hosted an initially seated crowd that ended the night jumping and dancing against the front of the stage. The trio performed a set focused on their recently released Sci-Fi Horror concept album, 'Splendor & Misery', then delved into their dancier and more aggressive back catalogue, and recent single 'Wriggle'. Opening performances included local experimental electronic duo 'Tujurikkuja' and computer music artist 'Madalyn Merkey.'"