Get SF Weekly Newsletters
Pin It
Critic's Corner: The End of a Long, Long Story The Chronicle promised us a horse race but didn't even provide a winner's circle after the handsome steed, bloodied but unbowed, finally made it across the finish line. When the paper quietly hired James Sullivan as second pop critic last Thursday, Datebook Editor Liz Lufkin ended a saga that's gone through more twists and turns than a cheap spy novel. A recap for those who might have missed a chapter in this epic story: For two years now, the Chron's haphazardly tried to find a youthful counterbalance to elder critic Joel Selvin's warhorse coverage. After several flirtations with writers both in S.F. and across the country, the paper asked regular free-lancer Sullivan to fill in for Selvin for six weeks earlier this summer. Riff Raff thought Sullivan performed sassily; but then, like a Saturday night Lothario in a North Beach bar, the paper's attentions wandered. Enter the extremely well-qualified Natasha Stovall, a New York emigre who during her trial period slayed the Chron with strong copy. Tensions mounted: Both were told the job was theirs to lose. Stovall and Sullivan behaved with grace, meeting for beers two weeks before the decision to forge a working relationship. "We were pitted against one another," says Sullivan. "But neither of us wanted to be scraping and clawing at the other." Sullivan is the 31-year-old hard-working Boston transplant who's written for Option, Request, BAM, and lots of other publications, including this one. He says the changes at the paper will be slight but noticeable now that he and Selvin share oversight of the daily's pop coverage. "Supposedly Joel and I will be sharing all responsibilities," says Sullivan. The two are meeting later this week to discuss changes for the music-news section in the Pink Pages. He says he'll also make sure that important shows don't get ignored and that the record reviews stay broad. We take his word for it. (J.S.)

Save the DJ It's about time DJs receive the respect and attention they deserve. We're talking about the first Global DJ Mix Awards, held last Sunday at 1015 Folsom, which honored the talents of turntablists from around the world. There are, of course, tons of DJ competitions out there, but the Global DJ Mix Awards were broader in scope -- they included all types of DJs from hip hop and jungle to techno and house -- and the judges for the competition were members of the Global DJ Academy, a collaborative that helps DJs with health insurance and legal issues. At 1015, when MC Foxee Brown finally quit rambling, the results showed how deep the Bay Area's talent pool really is. Local DJ Doc Martin cleaned house as the best Club DJ, DJ Shadow won best hip-hop DJ, and the Invisibl Skratch Piklz were awarded the best technical trick DJs. (R.A.)

Thanks But Thanks Most awards don't mean shit. Sure, local avant-popsters M.K. Ultra got the 11th track on a compilation CD for winning Musician magazine's "Best Unsigned Band" competition, but the perks really ended there. John Vanderslice, the band's guitarist, says the group sent in two songs from its Original Motion Picture Soundtrack CD back in 1996; he'd forgotten he'd even entered. (The Mo'fessionals, another San Francisco band, were also selected, along with 10 other groups from around the country.) Vanderslice says a Musician rep who called to tell him the group had won said that the band might have a chance to perform at a show in New York. "He said, 'We're not sure we can fly you out,' and I said, 'I guess we're not playing New York,' " says Vanderslice. The best part, says the guitarist, is imagining the Musician judges -- supposedly rock stars like Tori Amos, Bob Mould, and Buddy Guy -- sitting around together listening to M.K. Ultra songs. In the end, the Musician award provided personal amusement, but didn't attract much attention from peers or friends. You want real fame? You need Travel & Leisure. Among the photos in a spread about Portland, Ore., in last month's issue was a close-up of a bicycle graced with one of M.K. Ultra's distinctive red stickers. Vanderslice's phone rang like a fire bell on the Fourth of July. Friends from the East Coast, a cousin, and, most importantly, Vanderslice's mother in Bethesda, Md., all called him to report the sighting. Vanderslice says that's the power of images and huge circulation, which is fine with him because his band appreciates pure publicity more than trinkets from Musician magazine. "We are self-sufficient," says Vanderslice, dryly. "We don't have to win a Steve Vai guitar or a wireless microphone to propel us to stardom." (J.S.)

Selvin Watch Some people complain about this recurring Riff Raff feature: They say it's mean, say it's picky. Au contraire: We remind readers that in big-city journalism accuracy is supposed to matter, and that the multitudinous mistakes made by alleged Chron pop music critic Joel Selvin cry out for correction. Latest: In his review of Neil Young's Bridge Concert Monday, Selvin wrote: "[Smashing Pumpkins' Billy Corgan] scowled his way through 'Bullets With Butterfly Wings' and 'Rat in a Cage,' his raspy yowl sounding particularly naked in front of the spare acoustic sound." For the record, the song is "Bullet With Butterfly Wings." And there is no Pumpkins tune called "Rat in a Cage" -- that's just the chorus from "Bullet." (B.W.)

Third Eye Blind in HTML Can't get your fill of local-boys-made-pop-stars Third Eye Blind?! Got a computer?!! Wonder why we're using so many exclamation points?!!! Simple: We've just been surfing the Background (, a Web site devoted to lead singer Stephan Jenkins and company, and designed by 15-year-old San Francisco resident "Amber." In years past, Amber might've been writing fan letters to Teen Beat, but this is the '90s, and Amber has constructed her very own digital shrine to the MTV gods. And a shrine it is, piled high with photos, lyrics, tour dates, fan club info, and, oh yes, Amber herself. An excerpt: "The performance on Keenen Ivory Wayans was pretty killer, I loved all the camera work!!! And also, nice pigtails, Arion!" Our fave passage, though, has to be: "Story time!!! I was first exposed to Third Eye Blind when I saw them live in September of 1995. Me and my friend Ruby got there and they were a bit into their set. We got really into them (we were about the ONLY people getting really into them) and it was cool. We later talked to Stephan and asked him if they had an album out. He said they didn't, and we practically ordered him to put out an album so that we could buy it!" Thanks a lot, Amber. (Steve Boland)

2B12B3 Even though they're only celebrating their second birthday, the people behind Maritime Hall look like they're aiming for empire these days. This week Maritime's Boots Hughston and his band of happy hippies (aka 2B1 Productions) will reopen Santa Cruz's Palookaville nightclub. It's a bold move because for years a 1,000-plus capacity hall called the Catalyst has enjoyed a near monopoly on local concerts. Add to that an aggressive local government that keeps a lid on underage drinking, and the Maritime folks look like daredevils. No sweat, says the Maritime's Randy Merten. He says the plan is to drop a load on a new sound system for the 800-capacity Palookaville and to treat paying customers with respect. The new club's secret weapon: The Maritime's already picked up Gary Tigh, the Catalyst's former booker. That's one hand up in Santa Cruz; regionally, the new hall should give the Maritime organization some added clout with tour bookers. Now, one phone call could set up an artist with shows in San Francisco, Santa Cruz, and Petaluma, where 2B1 recently signed a deal to book shows at the Phoenix Theater. (J.S.)

AHabla Rock en Espanol? We've witnessed so many British Invasions in the States that the mere mention of Oasis might be enough to cause clubbers irreparable brain damage. However, those who've nailed their faux British accents and moppish haircuts might be a little unprepared for the next wave of musical imports. San Francisco's Aztlan Records is on the leading edge of the next musical invasion, coming from the South. Spanish-singing bands from the tip of South America all the way to L.A. have been touring and recording for years and are now heading north big time. Beginning on Oct. 26, Aztlan and Slim's will kick off a monthly "Alternativo Night," which will showcase national and international rock en Espanol artists. The first of this series will feature Aterciopelados ("The Velvety Ones"), a rock band from Colombia with a sound that ranges from folkish punk to Latin hip hop tinged with heavy metal. Opening the show is L.A.'s Pastilla, whose music, replete with touches of flamenco and ranchera rhythms, resembles what Smashing Pumpkins might sound like if they'd grown up in Juarez. Think that Latino rock began and ended with Menudo, or that Oasis still rules? Stay home. (R.A.)

Fire Down Below As Riff Raff reported several weeks ago, the Red Devil Lounge was ready to capture Julie Ring's Heart & Soul (ouch!), but new owner Rob Palmer didn't know what sorts of acts the club would book. Well, the Lounge is now open, serving up spicy cuisine and various fiery entertainment, from the funked-out rhythms of What It Is to Sunday night DJs spinning for an evening of fun called "Sin." Despite the hokey themes, the Red Devil Lounge isn't abandoning the, ahem, spirit left by Julie Ring's: jazz grooves and good martinis are permanent. The club brings a much-needed breath of fire to the chilly nightlife offered on Polk Street. (J.D.P.)

Riff Raff riffraff: Robert Arriaga (R.A.), Johnny DiPaola (J.D.P.), Karl D. Esturbense (K.D.E.), Jeff Stark (J.S.), Silke Tudor (S.T.), Heather Wisner (H.W.), and Bill Wyman (B.W.). Send Bay Area music news, band stories, or petty gripes to, or mail it to Riff Raff, c/o SF Weekly.


Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

Popular Stories

  1. Most Popular Stories
  2. Stories You Missed


  • clipping at Brava Theater Sept. 11
    Sub Pop recording artists 'clipping.' brought their brand of noise-driven experimental hip hop to the closing night of 2016's San Francisco Electronic Music Fest this past Sunday. The packed Brava Theater hosted an initially seated crowd that ended the night jumping and dancing against the front of the stage. The trio performed a set focused on their recently released Sci-Fi Horror concept album, 'Splendor & Misery', then delved into their dancier and more aggressive back catalogue, and recent single 'Wriggle'. Opening performances included local experimental electronic duo 'Tujurikkuja' and computer music artist 'Madalyn Merkey.'"