Get SF Weekly Newsletters
Pin It

An Open Letter to the Jaded Sonic Youth (Ex-) Fan 

It's time to get Ripped

Wednesday, Jul 12 2006
Dear fading daydream nation,

I know where you're at. You're fed up with Sonic Youth. You think the band has gone soft. You miss the signature guitar rave-ups of yesteryear. You're not feeling this older, quieter band that's been showing up on recent records. Let's talk this out. But be forewarned: If I have to listen to you bellyache that Daydream Nation was the band's apex or that Goo began their end run to commercial viability one more time, I'm gonna rub my dirty boots all over your first-edition, clear vinyl pressing of Marquis Moon. Quit your conjecturing — it's time to buckle down an5d spend some quality headspace with Sonic Youth's new album, Rather Ripped, a record that should reignite the fervor of fans who've recently begun to doubt the band's vitality.

Sure, we've watched OG indie-rockers like Yo La Tengo turn to the conventions of smooth jazz and adult contemporary to inform their once distortion-heavy nouveau-punk, a route that some naysayers have accused Sonic Youth of embarking upon as well. But realize that the members of SY, while busy with grown-up things like children, marriage, and Medicare, are still focusing their music into a vivacious, jagged-edge laser of free-form deconstructo-rock. The last two records did find the band forsaking much of its squealing, four-minute, free-jazz outros for melody and softer edges. But let's place some of the blame for that on SY's fifth Beatle, Jim O'Rourke, who started working with the group on the much-maligned NYC Ghosts and Flowers. Sonic Youth is back to its original four-piece incarnation on Ripped, though, a record that beautifully skirts the boundary between Sister and Murray Street, where guitar squalor and soundscapes happily meet.

All SY albums have their Thurston Moore songs, their Kim Gordon songs, and the oft-ignored little brother, their Lee Ranaldo songs. Rather Ripped is a bit heavy on the Kim side of things, which in the past has meant conceptually thrilling but sometimes aurally grating femi-riot themes. From the opening notes of "Reena," the Kim song that begins the new record, it's apparent that something is different here. Her singing has increased in both quantity and quality, from her Nico-like deadpan intonation on "What a Waste" to the joyfully melodic "The Neutral." But don't get it twisted — just because Kim's focusing more on notes than attitude, the vitriol of lyrics like "What a waste, you're so chaste" has not decreased. Ripped is not an all-Kim affair though, as exemplified by the lead single, "Incinerate." Yes, this is the "new" Sonic Youth, as Thurston and Lee intertwine guitar lines more concerned with dynamics than dissonance and Thurston uses his indoor singing voice. It's still a damn good song, and placed in the context of the sneering rock and piercing guitar-playing of "Sleepin' Around" and the harmonics-infused "Do You Believe in Rapture" — a song that could be a companion piece to "Shadow of a Doubt" (from 1986's Evol) — it's clear that the new SY still hangs with the old.

The proof is in the post-punk pudding, and if you think Sonic Youth has gone flaccid in its golden years, you're just not listening closely enough to Ripped. This is a record created by a band unafraid to stretch its legs as it grows, as is evident on the last few albums, but that still expounds upon the experimental vision it's had since day one. Blast the subtly squealing riffs and throbbing bass of "Rats," pay close attention to the mid-song feedback on "Turquoise Boy," and hell, go ahead and enjoy the experimental MOR soft-rock of "Or." Most importantly, understand that with this new album it's evident that the groundbreaking noise/art/punk band that's been teaching discord for over 25 years is now as thrilling as its ever been.

About The Author

Jonah Flicker


Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

Popular Stories

  1. Most Popular Stories
  2. Stories You Missed


  • clipping at Brava Theater Sept. 11
    Sub Pop recording artists 'clipping.' brought their brand of noise-driven experimental hip hop to the closing night of 2016's San Francisco Electronic Music Fest this past Sunday. The packed Brava Theater hosted an initially seated crowd that ended the night jumping and dancing against the front of the stage. The trio performed a set focused on their recently released Sci-Fi Horror concept album, 'Splendor & Misery', then delved into their dancier and more aggressive back catalogue, and recent single 'Wriggle'. Opening performances included local experimental electronic duo 'Tujurikkuja' and computer music artist 'Madalyn Merkey.'"