Get SF Weekly Newsletters
Pin It

A Load of Crap 

Is a new program to produce energy from dog poop a scientific breakthrough or just another zany idea out of San Francisco? Take our quiz and find out!

Wednesday, Mar 1 2006
Last week, city officials announced a groundbreaking program to turn dog doo into energy -- enough to power an electricity-generating turbine, a home stove, or anything else fueled by natural gas. San Francisco is the first city in the United States to launch such a pilot program, and waste management consultants say it's the perfect place to start: Residents here recycle more than 60 percent of their garbage, and animal feces make up nearly 4 percent of the 6,500 tons of residential waste produced annually. Within the next few months, Norcal Waste Systems employees will start using biodegradable bags and dog-waste carts to collect droppings at Duboce Park; the dung will then be tossed into a methane digester, a tank in which bacteria called methanogens break down carbon dioxide into microbial food. After a few weeks, methane gas is produced as a byproduct, which can be piped into any number of natural gas-generating devices. Still, some energy analysts believe the process is too expensive -- each methane digester costs about $1 million -- and point out that natural gas, electricity, and landfill space are comparatively cheap. Are you an apologist for the energy potential of dog poop? Take our quiz and find out!

1) When you first heard of the idea, what was your initial reaction?

A) You mean we weren't supposed to be recycling our dog poop? Oh, shit ....

B) Honestly, I'm still trying to figure out whether it's OK to recycle pizza boxes that have a little bit of cheese stuck to them. (Bonus point for adding: "In my experience, the answer is invariably 'yes.'")

C) Who'da thunk we'd be powering our cars on dog poop before we were driving them across a retrofitted Bay Bridge? What a world.

2) The technology behind methane digesters was introduced about 20 years ago in Europe, where more than 600 machines are now in use on farms. It has since spread to rural America: Nine operate on California dairy farms, and other livestock ranches -- especially chicken and hog farms -- also employ them. In addition, Third World countries have used more rudimentary versions of the device. As William Brinton, president of Woods End Laboratories Inc., a Maine company that specializes in compost technologies, told the Discovery News Web site: "Often Third World users just put animal waste in plastic bags that are placed into holes in the ground. Straws or tubing poked into the bags divert the gas into homes. You can then light the gas, and there's your heat." What do you think of the concept?

A) I'm no scientist, but I could have told you years ago that farts have the power to light up a room.

B) My God. Do you know what this means? If we could harness the energy from an average collegiate male road trip, we could power the space station!

C) How in the world did Bush not mention this during his push for renewable energy in the State of the Union address? Oh, right -- his aides knew he'd crack up.

3) For the past decade, San Francisco has been operating a groundbreaking food composting program: Norcal Waste Systems collects 300 tons of food scraps per day from homes and restaurants, which are then converted into fertilizer for vineyards and organic farms. With more than 240,000 cats and dogs living in S.F., officials now hope to take advantage of our reputation as an animal haven. "The city's asked us to look at dog waste specifically," says Norcal Waste spokesman Robert Reed. Do you think the program is the right fit for San Francisco?

A) Sure ... just don't look at dog waste too specifically, if you know what I mean.

B) Of course. The only problem I foresee in San Francisco is determining whether that pile of crap on the sidewalk is from a dog or a human.

C) Yes. I just wish we could also harness the rage of Noe Valley housewives whose neighbors' dogs drop one on their front lawns. The city would light up like a Christmas tree.

4) The technology has not yet advanced to the point that it's feasible to install smaller methane digester devices in private homes, but the digestion is nonhazardous, waste management experts say. "The resulting gas does not have much smell," Brinton said. "Sometimes there is a slight egglike sour odor in the containerized process, but this can be easily filtered out." Do you think the process sounds safe?

A) Sure. But filtered out by whom?

B) I don't know, but Bill Brinton must be the star of any cocktail party he attends.

C) Shoot, I was hoping we could get one for the house. Then I could tell Mom I'm just recycling, rather than preparing to deposit a flaming bag of poop on Old Man McRooney's front porch.

5) Now that you know more about the technology, do you have any particular questions for city and waste management officials?

A) Yeah, can they use bullshit? We've got plenty of that in San Francisco.

B) Hmm ... are you sure they'll be able to find enough dog crap in Duboce Park? (Bonus point for saying this with a straight face.)

C) No questions, unless they can tell me why every time I'm out walking my dog and bend down to pick up a big juicy one, an extraordinarily hot person who conforms to my sexual ideal walks by. Every fucking time.

6) Officials have decided to launch the program using dog waste in particular because, as Brinton said, "What's wonderful about dog manure is that it is very high in energy because of the rich diets we feed our pets." Do you agree?

A) Well, I'd probably be a bit more cautious about throwing around the word "wonderful" in relation to manure. But I'm not Bill Brinton.

B) That settles it -- my dog is going on an all-energy-bar diet. No more TV dinners.

C) Oh, and my cat's manure isn't wonderful, is that what you're saying?!?!?

7) Within the next few months, workers will begin patrolling Duboce Park for dog droppings, and if the test run is successful, a permanent bin will be set up there for collection. Will the program make you change any of your dog-walking and poop-collecting habits?

A) Yes! I'm actually going to pick it up now, instead of merely pretending to!

B) How can I put this? There is not a forward-thinking recycling program on God's green Earth that would cause me to absolve my teenage son of collecting our dog's crap in too-small, too-thin plastic bags. Sorry, but a man has to have one simple joy in life.

C) Wait a minute, I have a better idea: Is Norcal hiring?

How to score:

Score zero points for every "A" answer, one point for every "B," and two points for every "C."

0-6 points: Great, now cat lovers and dog lovers can argue about which species' poop is better. Just what we need at family gatherings.

7-10 points: Wow. This program could single-handedly make the Panhandle a safe place for humans to walk again.

11-14 points: Congratulations! You're a true apologist for dog doo's energy potential. And why the hell not? Get Fido to Duboce Park, pronto.

About The Author

Matt Palmquist


Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

Popular Stories

  1. Most Popular Stories
  2. Stories You Missed


  • clipping at Brava Theater Sept. 11
    Sub Pop recording artists 'clipping.' brought their brand of noise-driven experimental hip hop to the closing night of 2016's San Francisco Electronic Music Fest this past Sunday. The packed Brava Theater hosted an initially seated crowd that ended the night jumping and dancing against the front of the stage. The trio performed a set focused on their recently released Sci-Fi Horror concept album, 'Splendor & Misery', then delved into their dancier and more aggressive back catalogue, and recent single 'Wriggle'. Opening performances included local experimental electronic duo 'Tujurikkuja' and computer music artist 'Madalyn Merkey.'"