under fire for hisproposed charter amendment to allow the
non-citizen parents of students to vote in San Francisco school board
elections, Chiu is willing to say something unusual for a San Francisco
politician: We're not the first to do this; we're not even all that
Non-citizens voted in New York City school board elections from 1969 until the dissolution of school boards several decades ago and have voted in Chicago school board elections from 1989 to the present. Six different Maryland municipalities allow non-citizens to vote in local elections.
Chiu recites these facts off one by one as he thumbs through Democracy For All: Restoring Immigrant Voting Rights in the United States by professor Ron Hayduk of City University of New York. (Hayduk also has a website, which Chiu obviously checks frequently). Chiu is happy to inform anyone who'll listen that 22 states and territories allowed non-citizens to vote and even hold office from the nation's inception until as late as the 1920s. "This practice was encouraged by the founding fathers, who felt that voting gave immigrants a stake in this country," says Chiu.
Those of you with long memories may recall a previous effort to award non-citizens the right to vote helmed by Chiu. In 2004, Proposition F narrowly failed. While, yes, one San Francisco school child out of three has an immigrant parent and, yes, studies show parents who have a stake in their children's education have children who do better in school -- holding a special election for immigrants would cost a lot. How much? Close to $800,000 to essentially have a separate, same-day election.