Earlier this week, SF Weekly reported on how
Supervisor Michela Alioto-Pier is prepared to take the city to court if City Attorney Dennis Herrera doesn't reverse a 2008 ruling that deems her termed out next year. One of Alioto-Pier's main bones of contention was a 2004 Herrera ruling generously allowing former Supervisor Tom Ammiano a fourth term -- and 14 years -- on the Board.
Alioto-Pier pondered if the ruling had anything to do with Herrera and Ammiano's political compatability: "I asked [Herrera], 'Is this political?'" recalls Alioto-Pier, one of the board's moderate members. "He said, 'Of course not.'" (Herrera declined to speak with SF Weekly
regarding his ruling, stating he'll let it "speak for itself.")
Ammano, however, is happy to talk -- and he says that he was not the recipient of any political favors. In fact, he claims the legal decision that benefitted him actually did not originate from Herrera but his predecessor Louise Rennie -- who was hardly a progressive by any stretch.
"When we switched from at-large to district elections, the clerk of the board, John Taylor, asked Louise whether or not people would be termed out. Louise actually wrote an opinion on it and shared it with some of us, but didn't make it public," says Ammiano, now a San Francisco Assemblyman after serving as a Supe from 1994-2008. "When Herrera took over and this question was asked again, he basically re-issued the Louise Rennie ruling. There was no collusion there -- believe me, there was no wink-wink, nod-nod; it was all above board. I wish Michela luck, but why she's trying to intimate collusion, I don't know. But, whatever, it's politics. I wish her luck."
Ammiano noted that the Rennie-Herrera ruling is what has allowed Chris Daly and Sophie Maxwell to still serve on the board -- "it wasn't just me."
The Assemblyman added that he supported Alioto-Pier's challenge of the City Attorney's ruling. And if the courts have to get involved, so be it.
"I do like Michela and think she has every right to pursue this to the max," he said. "I like her and I think Dennis is a pretty straight shooter. Let the courts decide, how about that?"Photo | Steve Rhodes