This might seem like an odd thing to say about Franken. Like many comedians, from George "I was a loner as a child" Carlin to Richard "I never had any friends" Pryor, Franken readily admits that he doesn't fit in. His career trajectory thus far has included stints as a transcriptionist for TV news shows like 20/20 and Dateline, teaching in a Harlem middle school, touring university campuses dressed as an 18th-century French dandy on behalf of an online search company, typing real estate documents for an insurance firm on the graveyard shift in Charlotte, N.C., and living out of his car at the Berkeley Marina while selling art supplies, working as a receptionist, and hitting at least one open mike a night.
Franken's approach to performance is as hard to pin down as his peripatetic life story. Neither a stand-up comedian nor a solo theater performer in the traditional senses of both terms, Franken occupies the fuzzy space somewhere in between. Seeing the world as being full of self-contradiction and cultural anomaly, he's been accused, in equal parts, of being a communist and a neocon. And if all of the above doesn't make the scraggly looking, long-haired 6-foot-5-er a prize misfit, just look at how he spends his free time reading anything he can lay his hands on by or about Winston Churchill and watching every 3 1/2- or four-star movie in a film guide he owns, alternating titles from the front to the back. Franken expects "The Great Movie Project," as he dubs his celluloid adventure, to take around seven years to complete.
In the light of this, Grandpa It's Not Fitting seems like a fitting title for a Franken show. For, like its creator's life and hallucinogenic performance style, it chafes against standard rules of logic and reason. One of the most fascinating aspects of Franken's work is the way he collapses time frames and geographies together to create pungent new realities. Imitating the voice and aspect of a cheesy History Channel documentary presenter at one point during his show, Franken pokes fun at baby boomer nostalgia. "The 1960s. A time of change and exploration," he repeatedly intones like a malfunctioning machine. Suddenly, without warning, we're thrown backward into a different era. "The 1860s. A time of chaos and exploitation," chimes Franken in his History Channel voice. We've barely had time to acclimatize to the 19th century before Franken's moved on, this time to perform an interpretive dance about prison reform.
The contradictions in Franken's performance also play themselves out through his yo-yoing worldview. In one bit, he takes on the role of a Muslim suicide bomber, quietly reading the Koran on a plane with a bomb strapped to his tummy. When the plane goes down owing to some non-terrorism-related technical malfunction, he tries to enlist potential survivors to declare him responsible for the act. Elsewhere, Christianity is ridiculed when Franken, posing as a blustering British vicar, tucks references to Noam Chomsky and the Beatles into a cataclysmic religious debate. Franken's apparent disdain for all world religions takes its cue from Monty Python's Life of Brian. Then again, in a skit describing a protest against a small Christian gathering in Golden Gate Park, it's not the God-squadders but the militant anti-religion activists who become the subjects of Franken's satire. Franken's ethical stance is ultimately much less clear than that of the Pythons. He wants us to understand that the world we live in constantly defies categorization.
Sometimes, though, the effort that comes with trying to fit a square peg into a round hole becomes too much for us. In Franken's previous shows like 2005's Good Luck With It and Ohio! Ohio! Ohio! from 2004, I've kept up pretty well with the performer's dense layering of cultural references, tangled viewpoints, and stream-of-consciousness style. For buried somewhere in the depths of Franken's spasming imagination is usually the barest outline of a coherent theme. It's what makes him an artist rather than a raving lunatic. But there are times during Grandpa where "not fitting" becomes less about contradiction than confusion. Franken's opening skit concerning a discussion between a terminal breast cancer patient named Mrs. Wit and her physician, one Dr. Posner, about the movie version of the patient's life, contains so much oblique content that the performer risks losing us at the start. Impenetrable references to the Broadway production of the Pulitzer Prize-winning play, Wit, aside, it's hard to know what Franken is driving at with this material. It further doesn't help matters that Mrs. Wit appears to be a fly in Dr. Posner's ear.
Fortunately, there are few such ill-fitting moments in this show. For long stretches, Franken inhabits his material like it's custom-made Armani. And, interestingly enough, the most brilliant sequences in Franken's performance are all informed by Bay Area culture. This is nothing new for the comedian. He's long used the nutty-crunchy, politically correct face of this part of the world as a source of comic inspiration. But San Francisco makes its presence felt more strongly than ever before in this show. In a skit about the Beatles, for instance, Franken hilariously reimagines the Fab Four as an unknown band trying to make it in contemporary San Francisco. "Paul made fliers; he was very good with Photoshop," he says, imitating John Lennon's soft, Liverpudlian drawl. "George and Ringo would go to Kinkos to cut them out on the cutty-slidey thing. Meanwhile, I contacted the weeklies to get a listing." Sometimes the Bay Area spirit is more implicit. Franken's savagely funny sketch concerning the corporate world's hypocritical stabs at pseudo-activism is steeped in the business jargon of Silicon Valley. It's disturbingly easy to imagine a chirpy business consultant like Franken's Bill Jacobs persona, running motivational "celebrating diversity" seminars in a conference room down the hall.
Despite a desire to move away, Franken's five-year sojourn in San Francisco has clearly gotten under his skin. I went to see Grandpa thinking it would be my last Franken show for a while, but was relieved to hear that the performer has decided to stay after all. Makes sense to me. In this city of misfits, Franken fits right in. He's San Francisco's patron saint of misrule.