Mike wasn't always a ghoulish hack; we learn early on in this adaptation of a Stephen King short story that he was once a writer of serious, sincere fiction, notably a hard-to-find book called The Long Road Home about the relationship between a father and child. But there is a reason he's dropped such endeavors: Mike's daughter, Gracie (Jasmine Jessica Anthony), died of an unspecified illness; he and his wife, Lilly (Mary McCormack), separated; and he's abandoned all interest in the living to focus on the dead, in which there's better money to be made. People, he explains, will always want to "get a glimpse of that elusive light at the end of the tunnel." Suckers.
For all intents, Mike is kind of the walking dead a shell and a cynic so battered by Gracie's death he believes in nothing, spouting into his ubiquitous tape recorder contemptuous aphorisms intended to defend his position that nothing matters. (The recorder also serves as a convenient plot device, as Cusack's left alone for most of the film.) When, after his own near-death experience on a surfboard, he receives a postcard informing him of a room 1408 at the Dolphin Hotel in Manhattan, he believes it's yet one more empty promise of creaky floors and moldy tubs. But in the end, 1408 proves to be the hell he never believed in a room in which dozens of corpses have piled up since the 1920s, now off-limits to all comers thanks to the guardianship of hotel manager Mr. Olin (Samuel L. Jackson), who damns it as "an evil fucking room."
There was every reason going in to believe that 1408 would be nothing but reanimated Stephen King a Shining rip-off made on the cheap by the Brothers Weinstein. The screenwriters are collectively responsible for Reign of Fire, Problem Child 3, and Agent Cody Banks, and Cusack is not above taking a gig for the paycheck: Ever since America's Sweethearts six years ago, his flimsy filmography has proven surprisingly unreliable as cynical as Mike Enslin's own body of work. Combine this with the fact that director Mikael Håfström's sole English-language film was the dreadful Derailed, and 1408 seemed doomed.
Yet it's a surprisingly effective movie terrifying as it builds tension and heartbreaking as it offers release. And it works because King's enough of a humanist to root his terror not in the fantastic, but in the grim everyday in this case, the haunting of a parent by the ghost of his child. Yes, 1408 is a horror story in which the most terrifying things of all are the awful memories that plague us.
The film peddles all the horror movie clichés walls that bleed through the cracks, open windows that are suddenly and inexplicably bricked up, phantom slashers wielding knives, screams emanating from god-knows-where, the repeated use of the Carpenters' "We've Only Just Begun" but not without good reason. They are, in fact, essential concessions to the genre's formula though to explain why would give away too much about 1408, which suggests that everything Mike experiences in that room is taking place in his head. (It's far more open-ended than the original short story, which King initially wrote as an experiment he intended to abandon.)
And none of this would work were it not for Cusack. What could have been a rote acting exercise Be tough! Now be angry! Now be defensively funny! Now tough again! Cry, damn it, cry! plays as it's intended: as a cathartic ritual. We're never sure if Mike's losing his mind or saving his soul. More than likely, it's a bit of both.